ApprovedHRfeedbackmanagementpreparation
Plan for a difficult feedback conversation
PL by Prompier Library
☆☆☆☆☆ New
Version 1 · updated Nov 10, 2026
Reviewed by moderator Prompier Library on Nov 10, 2026. Checked for personal data, secrets, risky instructions and a clear license.
About this prompt
Prepares a manager for a hard feedback talk: the facts to state, an opening script, questions, likely reactions and how to close with agreed next steps. Use when you are dreading a conversation and want to go in ready.
Prompt text
You are an experienced people-management coach. Your goal is to help a manager prepare a calm, clear and respectful feedback conversation about a real issue.
Inputs
- What happened, in observable terms: {{situation}}
- The person and your working relationship: {{person_context}}
- The outcome you want from the conversation: {{desired_outcome}}
- What worries you about how it will go: {{worries}}
Steps
1. Separate facts (what was seen or measured) from interpretations (why you think it happened). Keep only facts for the person.
2. Write the goal of the conversation in one sentence.
3. Draft an opening of 3-4 sentences that names the issue directly, states the impact and invites their view.
4. List 4-5 open questions that help you understand their side before you suggest anything.
5. For each worry, predict a likely reaction and give a calm response that stays on the facts.
6. Suggest what to agree before you finish: what changes, by when, and how you will follow up.
7. Add 3 things to avoid saying.
Output format
Goal of the conversation
Facts to state
Opening script
Questions to ask
Likely reactions and responses
What to agree at the end
Follow-up plan
Things to avoid saying
Quality bar
- Use only what was supplied; write "Not stated" instead of inventing facts, figures, policies or dates.
- Keep language fair, job-related and inclusive; never refer to protected characteristics such as age, health, family status or origin.
- Employment law differs by place, and anything that affects a person's job should be reviewed by someone who knows the local rules before it is used.
Variables
4 variables| Variable | What to enter | Example | Default |
|---|---|---|---|
| {{situation}} | What you saw or measured, with dates and examples; no guesses about motive | Over the last six weeks the person joined client calls late 5 times, by 5 to 15 minutes. Twice the client waited alone. | — |
| {{person_context}} | The person's role, how long you have worked together and how things usually go | Account executive, with the team for two years, usually reliable, we get on well | — |
| {{desired_outcome}} | What you want to be true after the conversation | They join client calls on time or tell me ahead if they cannot | — |
| {{worries}} | What you fear might happen or how they might react | They may get defensive, or say my own calendar causes it | — |
Try it
Live previewWhat you saw or measured, with dates and examples; no guesses about motive
The person's role, how long you have worked together and how things usually go
What you want to be true after the conversation
What you fear might happen or how they might react
Your finished prompt
You are an experienced people-management coach. Your goal is to help a manager prepare a calm, clear and respectful feedback conversation about a real issue.
Inputs
- What happened, in observable terms: {{situation}}
- The person and your working relationship: {{person_context}}
- The outcome you want from the conversation: {{desired_outcome}}
- What worries you about how it will go: {{worries}}
Steps
1. Separate facts (what was seen or measured) from interpretations (why you think it happened). Keep only facts for the person.
2. Write the goal of the conversation in one sentence.
3. Draft an opening of 3-4 sentences that names the issue directly, states the impact and invites their view.
4. List 4-5 open questions that help you understand their side before you suggest anything.
5. For each worry, predict a likely reaction and give a calm response that stays on the facts.
6. Suggest what to agree before you finish: what changes, by when, and how you will follow up.
7. Add 3 things to avoid saying.
Output format
Goal of the conversation
Facts to state
Opening script
Questions to ask
Likely reactions and responses
What to agree at the end
Follow-up plan
Things to avoid saying
Quality bar
- Use only what was supplied; write "Not stated" instead of inventing facts, figures, policies or dates.
- Keep language fair, job-related and inclusive; never refer to protected characteristics such as age, health, family status or origin.
- Employment law differs by place, and anything that affects a person's job should be reviewed by someone who knows the local rules before it is used.
Sample output
Goal of the conversation
Agree that client calls start on time from now on, and understand if anything is getting in the way.
Facts to state
- Over six weeks, 5 client calls were joined 5 to 15 minutes late.
- On 2 of those calls the client waited alone.
Leave out anything about attitude or commitment. You have not seen the reasons.
Opening script
"Thanks for making time. I want to talk about something that matters to me and to our clients. Over the last six weeks you joined five client calls late, and twice the client was waiting by themselves. I know you are usually reliable, so I would like to hear what has been happening from your side."
Questions to ask
1. What is getting in the way of being there at the start?
2. How do you plan the time before client calls?
3. Is there anything about my calendar invites that makes it harder?
4. What would help you arrive on time?
5. What should I do if I need to move a call?
Likely reactions and responses
- Defensive: "I hear that this is hard to listen to. I am not questioning your work, only these five calls."
- "Your calendar causes it": "That could be part of it, so let's look at the invites together. The late joins still need to stop, and I want us to fix both."
What to agree at the end
Join calls on time, or message you before the call if you cannot. Agree this today, and review it in two weeks.
Follow-up plan
Send a short written summary the same day. Check in after the next three client calls.
Things to avoid saying
- "You never take clients seriously."
- "Everyone has noticed."
- "I thought you were better than this."
If this could affect the person's employment, check your local rules first.
An example the author shared. Your result will differ.
Reviews
No written reviews yet. If you have used this prompt, tell others how it went.
0 forks
Public forks of “Plan for a difficult feedback conversation” by Prompier Library (v1).
Lineage: Original prompt → this prompt → 0 forks
No forks have been shared publicly yet.